Is A Medpor Implant Or Rib Graft Better For Ear Reconstruction?

Q: Dr. Eppley, I have some queries about Medpor implant surgery. One of my one friends, who is age 26, is looking for ear reshaping surgery. I have a concern about him, I am suggesting him to go for own body material surgery not with medpor implant surgery. Can you give us some guideline on this. Like as which one will be the best for his future.

A: While it is not clear from your inquiry as to the nature of your friend’s ear deformity, I will assume that it is either a subtotal or total ear reconstruction. (variations of congenital microtia or traumatic amputation) That would be the only consideration in which either a synthetic implant, like Medpor, or the use of a rib graft would be debated. There are arguments for the use of Medpor vs. rib grafts and I have done both successfully. (although many more rib grafts than medpor implants) I would agree that the use of rib cartilages are far safer and have much less risk of any long-term complications, in fact there would be few if any long-term issues with a natural material. But if one uses a Medpor implant in the ear it is absolutely critical that a temporalis fascial rotation flap is used to cover the implant to put more of a vascularized cover over most of the implant. This will substantially reduce the long-term risk of skin breakdown and implant exposure.

The reality is that while many patients and some surgeons think that using a synthetic implant is ‘easier’ than harvesting and carving rib grafts for ear reconstruction, it is not just as simple as pulling a preformed ear out of a box and sticking it under the skin. The success of synthetic ear reconstructions depends on the quality of the overlying ear skin and the surrounding tissues and getting good vascularized cover which means rotating a fascial flap. Successful long-term results from ear reconstruction, whether it is done by autologous or synthetic materials, requires experienced presurgical judgment and technical experience in performing them.

Dr. Barry Eppley